Why Anxiety Needs Control and Fears Judgement

If someone asked me to summarise anxiety in just two words, I think I could.

Control.

Judgement.

Now, before anyone points out that anxiety is far more complicated than that, I completely agree. Anxiety is influenced by genetics, life experiences, trauma, personality, physical health, hormones, stress, and countless other factors. Every person's experience is unique, and there will never be one explanation that fits everybody.

But after living with anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder for most of my life, and after spending years creating tools that help people understand their own minds, I have noticed something interesting.

When you keep asking "Why?", many anxious thoughts eventually lead back to one of two places.

Either we are desperately trying to control something that cannot be controlled.

Or we are frightened of being judged by other people.

Once I started recognising these patterns in my own thinking, anxiety became much less mysterious. It did not disappear overnight, but it became something I could understand instead of something that simply happened to me.

That understanding changed everything.

Anxiety and the Fear of Being Judged

Let's start with judgement.

You might be reading this thinking, "I honestly don't care what other people think."

I used to say the same thing.

But if we're really honest with ourselves, very few of us are born believing that. Somewhere along the way, we learned to compare ourselves to other people, to worry about fitting in, and to become aware of how we might be perceived.

For most people, those lessons begin long before adulthood.

Think back to secondary school.

Puberty has an incredible way of making us hyper-aware of ourselves. We suddenly become conscious of our appearance, our clothes, our friendships, our popularity and whether we are saying or doing the "right" things. We compare ourselves constantly, often without even realising it, because fitting in feels incredibly important during those years.

Our brains are wired to seek belonging because, historically, belonging meant survival.

Although life looks very different today, our nervous system has not caught up. Being judged still feels threatening, even when there is no real danger.

As we grow older, those worries simply change shape.

Instead of worrying about fitting in at school, we worry about saying something embarrassing during a meeting, and instead of wondering whether people like us, we worry about making mistakes in public.

Instead of fearing rejection from classmates, we fear criticism from colleagues, friends or even strangers online.

The situations change.

The underlying fear often stays remarkably similar.

Why Anxiety Needs Control: Keep Asking Why?

One of the most useful things I have ever learned is to never stop asking why.

Imagine somebody tells me they feel anxious every time they get on a bus.

I could accept that as the final answer or I could become curious.

Why does getting on a bus make you anxious? Because there are lots of people.

Why does that matter? Because I might embarrass myself.

How? Maybe I'll feel unwell.

And if you did? People would probably stare.

Would they? Maybe.

Would you ever see those people again? Probably not.

By the time you reach the end of that conversation, the fear often looks very different from where it started.

The bus was never really the problem.

The real fear was being judged.

This is something anxiety does exceptionally well.

It disguises the real problem behind a hundred smaller worries, leaving us trying to avoid buses, shops, restaurants or social events when the underlying issue has never actually changed.

This is exactly why I designed the Discovery Journal around recognising patterns rather than simply recording emotions. When you begin writing down situations, thoughts, behaviours and outcomes, you stop relying on memory and start collecting evidence. Over time, you begin to notice that the same fears often appear in completely different situations, making it much easier to understand what your anxiety is really trying to tell you.

Discovery Journal - Teal

From£24.99

Buy Now

The Story Anxiety Tells Us

One thing I find fascinating is how convincing anxiety can be.

When we are anxious, our brain behaves as though every thought deserves immediate attention.

• "What if something goes wrong?"

• "What if I embarrass myself?"

• "What if everyone notices?"

• "What if I panic?"

The strange thing is that we rarely stop to question those thoughts.

We simply accept them.

If somebody else made those predictions about our lives every single day, we would probably stop listening to them quite quickly. Yet when the voice comes from inside our own head, we treat it as though it must be telling the truth.

Learning to question those thoughts is one of the most valuable skills we can develop.

Not because it stops anxiety altogether, but because it stops anxiety from becoming the only voice in the conversation.

Why Anxiety Wants Control

The second theme I see repeatedly is control.

Now, I may have a slightly biased perspective because I have lived with obsessive-compulsive disorder for as long as I can remember, but if there is one thing anxiety hates, it is uncertainty.

Our brains are prediction machines.

Modern life moves incredibly quickly. We are expected to respond instantly, make decisions constantly and absorb huge amounts of information every single day. It is no wonder our brains begin searching for something they can control.

If we cannot control the world around us, anxiety encourages us to control ourselves instead.

• Our routines.

• Our behaviours.

• Our thoughts.

• Our environment.

Sometimes those behaviours seem harmless.

Other times, they become exhausting.

When Control Becomes The Problem

Think about the last time you felt really anxious.

Were you somewhere completely familiar, or were you somewhere unpredictable?

Most anxiety appears when we step outside our comfort zone because uncertainty naturally activates our nervous system.

The irony is that the harder we try to remove uncertainty, the more anxious we often become.

We check our phones again.

We ask for reassurance.

We replay conversations.

We prepare for every possible outcome.

For a few minutes, those behaviours may make us feel better.

Then the uncertainty returns.

So we repeat them.

Without realising it, we begin feeding the very anxiety we are trying to reduce.

Anxiety Is Trying To Protect You

This is perhaps the most important thing to remember.

Anxiety is not trying to ruin your life; it is trying to protect it.

The problem is that your nervous system cannot always tell the difference between genuine danger and imagined danger.

Thousands of years ago, this response kept humans alive.

Today it activates before presentations, first dates, exams, job interviews and social events.

• Your heart races.

• Your muscles tense.

• Your breathing changes.

Your body prepares for danger long before your logical brain has caught up.

Understanding this can be incredibly reassuring because it reminds us that anxiety is not evidence that something bad is about to happen.

It is simply a nervous system doing its best with the information it has.

Curiosity Changes Everything

For years, I thought the goal was to get rid of anxiety completely.

Now I think differently.

The goal is to understand it.

Because once you understand something, it becomes far less frightening.

Instead of asking: "Why am I like this?"

Try asking: "What is my anxiety trying to protect me from?"

Instead of assuming every anxious thought is true, ask:

• "Is this about judgement?"

• "Is this about control?"

• "Is there another explanation?"

Those small questions have completely changed the way I respond to my own anxiety.

If you often find yourself stuck in repetitive overthinking, the Breaking the Loop Digital Expansion is designed to help you challenge anxious thought patterns in a structured way. Rather than endlessly going round in circles, it helps you question automatic assumptions, recognise thinking traps and gradually develop more balanced ways of responding.

A Final Thought

Anxiety is complicated, but that does not mean it is impossible to understand.

For me, so many anxious thoughts eventually lead back to one of two things: trying to control what cannot be controlled, or worrying about what other people might think.

Neither of those fears makes you weak.

They make you human.

The next time anxiety shows up, instead of trying to silence it immediately, try becoming curious.

Ask why.

Ask it again.

Keep following the thread until you reach the real fear underneath.

You may be surprised by what you discover.

And once you understand your patterns, you are no longer simply reacting to anxiety.

You are learning from it.